Justice Shekhar Statement undermines Judicial Prestige: Mahmood Madani

New Delhi | December 11, 2024 : Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind President Maulana Mahmood Asa’d Madani has expressed strong disapproval of the controversial remarks made by Allahabad High Court Judge Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav, stating that his comments have tarnished the credibility and impartiality of the judiciary.

Maulana Madani emphasized that the judiciary’s role is to uphold justice and unify all sections of society, not to promote divisive rhetoric.

He criticized Justice Yadav for failing to act as a protector of the Constitution. “Justice Yadav’s statements are contrary to constitutional values and the principles of judicial impartiality,” Maulana Madani asserted.

The controversy arose from remarks made by Justice Yadav during a Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) event, where he claimed that the country should be governed according to the wishes of the majority.

He further criticized Muslim personal laws and used derogatory language to refer to certain members of the Muslim community, branding some of them as “Kath Mullah”. The Judge also linked the community’s cultural practices, such as animal slaughter, to a supposed lack of empathy in children.

Maulana Madani condemned these remarks as inflammatory and divisive, fearing that such rhetoric could undermine communal harmony and diminish public trust in the judiciary’s impartiality. “The judiciary’s role is to protect the Constitution and the rights of all citizens, irrespective of their religion or background,” he stated.

He further highlighted the exemplary role played by honest and impartial judges who strengthen the credibility of the judiciary and ensure justice for all. In contrast, Justice Yadav’s conduct, according to Maulana Madani, has damaged the institution’s reputation and raised questions about its neutrality.

Calling for an immediate investigation into Justice Yadav’s conduct, Maulana Madani urged Parliament and the Chief Justice of India to address the issue seriously and take necessary action to safeguard the judiciary’s integrity.

“The sanctity of the judiciary must be protected, and any actions that erode its credibility must be dealt with firmly,” he declared.

Maulana Madani also praised former judges and legal professionals who have consistently stood for truth and justice. He stressed the need for unity among such voices to counter the growing threat of communalism in the country, stating that a unified effort is essential to preserve India’s democratic values and social cohesion.

Please follow and like us: